By Jay Reeves/The Associated Press
BIRMINGHAM, Ala. — An Alabama judge on Thursday acquitted the man accused of drowning his newlywed wife during a honeymoon diving trip to Australia eight years ago, saying in an unusual ruling that prosecutors did not prove the man intentionally killed his wife to collect on a life insurance policy.
Circuit Judge Tommy Nail issued his ruling before the defense had even presented its case in the two-week-long trial and before jurors were given the case to deliberate. Prosecutor Don Valeska, head of the violent crimes division for the state attorney general’s office, said he never before had a trial end in a judge’s acquittal in 41 years of trying cases.
Gabe Watson, 34, had faced life in prison without parole if convicted of murdering his wife, Tina Thomas Watson, in 2003. He already served 18 months in an Australian prison after pleading guilty there to a manslaughter charge involving negligence.
Nail agreed with defense arguments that prosecutors failed to show Watson intentionally killed the woman. Prosecutors claimed he drowned her for insurance money, but the only eyewitness testified he thought Watson was trying to save the woman.
The state’s evidence was “sorely lacking” and did not prove Watson had any financial motive.
“I don’t think anyone knows for sure what happened in the water down there,” Nail said. He repeatedly clashed the prosecutors during both the trial and earlier hearings.
Defense attorneys had argued that Watson didn’t stand to gain anything monetarily because Tina Watson’s father was the beneficiary of her life insurance policy. They contended her death was an accident.
Gabe Watson’s father, David, hugged his son in the courtroom after the judge made his ruling. He said every court that had looked at the case determined Gabe did not intentionally kill his wife.
“I’m just so relieved. Hopefully he can put his life back together,” David Watson said.
“I hope everyone can begin to heal. The rest of his life will determine his legacy. Gabe is a good kid.”
Gabe Watson left the courtroom hand-in-hand with his second wife without commenting to reporters.
Tina Watson’s father, Tommy Thomas, had testified earlier in the day. He described how his family’s grief and shock over Tina Watson’s death turned to suspicion of Gabe Watson.
Valeska, the prosecutor, walked with his arm around Tommy Thomas, who appeared to be in shock and stunned by the judge’s decision.
“It should have gone to the jury for them to decide,” Thomas said of the judge’s decision.
Thomas had testified earlier that shortly after the death, his wife, Cindy, was worried about Gabe Watson’s condition. However, evidence showed relations between Watson and his wife’s family frayed quickly as the Thomases began having doubts about what happened and Gabe Watson began asking for Tina Watson’s belongings.
Gabe Watson’s father called to tell them about the woman’s death more than 15 hours after she drowned, Thomas said, and Tina Watson’s family never heard from Gabe Watson until they attempted to contact him through the U.S. consulate in Australia.
Thomas said that in a phone call from Australia, Watson claimed his wife gave him a thumbs up underwater, indicating she wanted to go back to the surface. Watson said he was leading her back to a rope when she panicked, knocked off his mask and air hose, and began sinking, according to Thomas.
But during a later talk at a lawyer’s office, Thomas said, Watson changed his story and said the woman indicated she wanted to go back to the rope leading to the top rather than go directly to the surface. Staring directly at Watson from the witness stand, Thomas said he asked his former son-in-law at that time: “When Tina gave him the thumbs up sign to go to the surface, why didn’t he just take her to the surface?”
The judge blocked Thomas from testifying about Watson’s alleged desire to increase the woman’s life insurance policy, a blow for prosecutors who earlier had been barred from presenting other evidence about Watson’s actions after the death.