Stun gun death case before federal appeals court

Court NewsJACK ELLIOTT JR.,Associated Press

JACKSON, Miss. (AP) — A Mississippi family is asking a federal appeals court to reinstate their multimillion dollar wrongful death lawsuit against the city of Cleveland, Miss., and two police officers.

The lawsuit was filed by the family of Jermaine Williams, who died in 2010 after being jolted twice by police stun guns. The family sought $25 million in damages.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans has scheduled the case for oral arguments on Sept. 4.

Williams, 30, died July 23, 2010, in a confrontation with two officers responding to a call about loiterers.

Authorities said officers found what they believed to be a bag of cocaine, which Williams allegedly grabbed and ran. Officers used the stun guns to subdue Williams when he became combative.

Williams died later at a local hospital.

City officials said experts had trained officers on the use of stun guns.

U.S. District Judge Sharion Aycock in north Mississippi dismissed the lawsuit in 2012, ruling that the officers’ conduct did not rise to the level of reckless disregard. She also dismissed the family’s product liability claim against the stun gun manufacturer.

The case is among several from Mississippi before the 5th Circuit in its September term.

In a second stun gun case, Dawn Melissa Daigre is appealing the dismissal of her lawsuit against the city of Waveland, Miss. The 5th Circuit has set the case for oral arguments on Sept. 4 in El Paso, Texas.

U.S. District Judge Louis Guirola in Gulfport, Miss., dismissed Daigre’s lawsuit in 2012.

Daigre sued Waveland for damages incurred during her February 2010 arrest.

The city contended that because Daigre pleaded guilty to resisting arrest, she is barred from challenging that ruling in the lawsuit.

The lawsuit argued that Daigre was 16 weeks pregnant when officers broke down her front door, apparently responding to a domestic disturbance call. Daigre said officers shocked her even though she’d told them she was pregnant. She gave birth to a girl five months later.

Daigre’s attorney said she pleaded guilty only because she was offered a plea to get out of jail, and that should not have absolved officers from liability.

Guirola said in his ruling that the law was clear.

“Daigre protests in her pleadings that she entered a guilty plea simply so that she would be released from prison,” Guirola sad. “That may be the case, but under the law, she cannot now seek damages based on an assertion that despite her guilty plea, she did not actually commit any offense.”

  • Americasgone

    Poor Jermaine. Too bad he had cocaine on him and decided to fight the cops. That is a special kind of stupid.