KABUL, Afghanistan – The talk of talks with the Taliban has taken on new momentum in the wake of the death of Osama bin Laden.
Even as the Taliban was mounting its spring offensive, Afghan officials told me of recent meetings in Qatar and Germany between U.S. officials and a Taliban official named Tayyeb Agha, who may – or may not – be an emissary of Mullah Omar.
And there lies the rub.
Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton has called for a diplomatic surge that will build on military gains produced by the U.S. troop surge. The hope is that Mullah Omar and his Quetta shura (core Taliban leaders) might be sobered by the U.S. ability to hit bin Laden and to break up their networks, and thus be willing to reconcile.
Yet conversations with U.S. and Afghan officials and members of the former Taliban government make clear that, even today, no one is certain who can speak for Omar.
“We encourage the United States to hold these meetings to find out if there is something serious,” I was told by President Hamid Karzai’s national security adviser, Rangin Dadfar Spanta, at the heavily guarded presidential palace.
“We have had serious contacts with Taliban,” he went on, “but the question is, are they in charge, are they representative of the Quetta shura? They have to prove it.”
Spanta added that “the United States itself is not sure” about the bona fides of Agha, a man in his mid-30s with a thin beard, who used to head Omar’s international relations committee. “Is he really Tayyeb Agha? Is he still the representative of Mullah Omar? We have to prove it.”
And that is only the beginning of the hurdles that confront an effort to get the Taliban to talks.
Mohamed Masoom Stanekzai, the professorial secretary of the Afghan High Peace Council, says it is essential that “the Taliban should have an office,” with a representative who could speak for its leaders. In other words, the Taliban should set up a political front group like a Sinn Fein.
Stanekzai says such an office should be located outside of Pakistan, where the Quetta shura is based, so Taliban reps could operate free from control by Pakistan’s ISI intelligence agency. Many Afghans are convinced the ISI would block any talks that it could not direct.
But all this begs the question of whether the Taliban is really interested in talks or has clear negotiating positions, beyond its demand that foreign troops leave Afghanistan.
“Mullah Omar wants an Islamic emirate and says, ‘We will never share power with anybody,’ ” says Waheed Mozhdah, a writer who worked in the Taliban government for five years. “They think they’ve defeated the United States, like they defeated the Soviet Union, and this is the start of another era.”
Mozhdah has argued with Taliban friends that Afghanistan has gained little from defeating the Soviets, and needs economic development more than another such victory.
U.S. and Afghan officials have laid down clear red lines: For any talks to succeed, the Taliban must break with al-Qaeda, accept the Afghan constitution, and play by democratic rules.
Would the Karzai government offer a power-sharing deal that guaranteed the Taliban control of certain provinces or ministries? “Absolutely not,” said Spanta.
So here we have it. We don’t know who speaks for the Taliban or what they want, or whether Mullah Omar could deliver a fragmented organization, even if he wanted to do so. We don’t know if a way can be found to bring Pakistan productively into the negotiating process.
Moreover, a majority of the Afghan population opposes any deal that might foster a Taliban regime redux.
And yet, despite all of the above, there are good reasons to keep exploring talks, so long as it is done without illusions. Perhaps the Quetta shura is tiring. Perhaps the movement is splitting. We need to find out.
So proceeding with caution is warranted, with no illusions that talks are imminent or a panacea. As a first step some detective work is urgently needed: Find out if Tayyeb Agha is for real.
Trudy Rubin writes on foreign affairs for The Philadelphia Inquirer, where she serves as a member of the editorial board. Contact her at email@example.com.