At one point, it looked like the precocious freshman had run out of magic.
Turns out he was just getting warmed up.
Shaking off more than three quarters of mistake-riddled football, Manziel rushed for a 29-yard touchdown and then threw a 20-yard touchdown pass to Swope in the fourth quarter as Texas A&M rallied for a 30-27 victory over Mississippi on Saturday night.
"That's the most emotional game I've ever played in," Swope said. "I walked off with tears in my eyes. But the guys were hungry and we never gave up."
Manziel accounted for 320 yards of total offense — 191 passing and 129 rushing. The Aggies (4-1, 2-1 Southeastern Conference) won despite a season-high six turnovers, including four fumbles and two interceptions.
"A year ago this team couldn't seem to close these games out," first-year Texas A&M coach Kevin Sumlin said. "But for us to go on the road in the SEC and to win is something we'll take a lot of confidence from."
Ole Miss (3-3, 0-2) made a final drive but Texas A&M's Toney Hurd, Jr., intercepted a Bo Wallace pass and the Aggies were able to run out the clock.
It was a gut-wrenching loss for the Rebels, who lost their 16th straight conference game dating back to 2010.
Jeff Scott rushed for 108 yards and a touchdown. Wallace completed 20 of 34 passes for 305 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions. He also rushed for a touchdown.
Ole Miss had a 27-17 lead midway through the fourth quarter and Texas A&M pinned on its own 1-yard line with less than eight minutes remaining.
But Manziel connected on a 32-yard, third-down pass to Mike Evans to give the Aggies some breathing room. Then in just two plays, Texas A&M drove the rest of the field for a quick touchdown. Ben Malena gashed the Rebels' defense for 36 yards before Manziel rushed for a 29-yard score — dancing past several would-be tacklers — to make it 27-23.
On the ensuing drive, first-year Ole Miss coach Hugh Freeze made a questionable decision to go for it on fourth-and-1 in his own territory.
It turned out to be a disastrous call. Scott was stuffed at the Ole Miss 39.
"We haven't won an SEC game in however long it's been, but I was just going for it," Freeze said. "Everybody can sit back and second-guess, but I was giving our kids what I thought was the best chance to win the game. Obviously I wish I would have called something different now, but we would go for it again."
Texas A&M needed just four plays after the crucial stop for Manziel to find Swope for the game-winning score.
"Johnny just checked into the corner route," Swope said. "That ball was up there for a while. But it's a play I had to make, and it's great."
Manziel completed 17 of 26 passes. Evans caught eight passes for 105 yards.
Manziel — the 6-foot-1, 200-pound redshirt freshman with a penchant for highlight-reel plays — was coming off a breakout game against Arkansas that included 557 total yards and four touchdowns.
He looked much more mortal against the Rebels — at least for a while. There were a couple of huge plays, like his 38-yard scramble in the third quarter to push the Aggies deep into Ole Miss territory. But his risk-taking had a downside, too, like four plays later when he lost a fumble on the Ole Miss 21 to stop an almost certain scoring drive.
Manziel made another crucial mistake early in the fourth quarter, deftly avoiding the Ole Miss rush before making a bad pass over the middle that was intercepted by Cody Prewitt.
But if Manziel was frustrated, he didn't show it. And then he led the Aggies to their second victory in their new conference.
"You have to believe and you have to keep playing. Period," Sumlin said. "This game was proof of that."
Texas A&M struck first on the opening drive after Malena burst through a huge hole and ran untouched 59 yards for a touchdown and 7-0 lead.
But the Ole Miss defense tightened considerably after that hiccup, while the offense improved as the first half progressed.
The Rebels took a 17-10 lead on a 14-yard run by Wallace — one play after he hit Randall Mackey on a 68-yard pass.
Then the Aggies fumbled on their own 35 — their third turnover of the half — and the Rebels had a chance to create some separation on the scoreboard.
But Ole Miss couldn't take advantage. Wallace was hit as he threw and the ball fell right to Texas A&M linebacker Steven Jenkins, who ran for the easy 37-yard touchdown that tied the game at 17 going into halftime.
It was one of a handful of plays the Rebels would like to have back.
"I know they're hurting and we all won't sleep tonight," Freeze said. "I know it's disappointing. You pour your heart and soul into this. ... You'll stay up all night and think of everything that you could have done different to affect the outcome, but tomorrow we'll come back and we'll get past it and move on."
Follow David Brandt on Twitter: www.twitter.com/davidbrandtAP
Click here for photo gallery of the game.
Read more in Sunday's NEMS Daily Journal newspaper.
Video highlights below.